How Profyt Helps You Choose the Right Mutual Funds

How Profyt Helps You Choose the Right Mutual Funds

The Profyt framework is built on three principles:

1. Defined. Every decision maps to a clear rule or threshold, written down in advance.

2. Objective. Funds are compared on numbers, against their own peer group. Each judgement is backed by a scored rubric.

3. Consistent. Every input comes from published market and fund data, refreshed on a fixed schedule.

The overall process has four steps: understanding the investor, setting the asset mix, selecting schemes, and reviewing on a schedule. This note explains the last two: how schemes are selected and how they are reviewed.

Choosing each scheme

The fund selection process has 5 stages. At every stage, a fund is compared only with other funds in its own category, so a small cap fund is assessed against other small cap funds, not against large cap funds.

1. Eligibility

Before any scoring, a fund must have at least 3 years of NAV history and ₹500 crore or more in assets under management. A shorter history does not give enough data to measure performance across different market conditions, and the asset threshold filters out very small schemes. Funds that do not meet both conditions are not ranked.

2. Score

Eligible funds are scored on 14 factors, grouped into returns, consistency and risk-adjusted measures. Each factor is ranked against the other funds in the same category, and the ranks are combined into a single score out of 100. This shows how a fund compares with its direct peers, rather than with the market as a whole.

3. Market lens

The weight given to each group of factors depends on how expensive the market is. When valuations are at fair value or cheaper, returns carry 30% of the score; when markets are deeply overvalued, that falls to 20% and the weight on risk-adjusted measures rises to 55%. This gives more importance to downside protection when markets are expensive.

4. Quality gates

Funds are then checked against qualitative conditions. The current fund manager must have run the scheme for at least 3 years, so the track record reflects their decisions; the fund house must have had no SEBI enforcement action in the last 3 years; and the portfolio must stay true to its category, for example a large cap fund that actually holds large caps. A fund that fails any of these is kept off the shortlist and reviewed manually.

5. Shortlist

The top 3 funds in each category, by score, make the shortlist. The research team then adds a qualitative overlay through meetings with fund managers and AMC product teams, covering areas such as portfolio construction and the manager's views ahead. Shortlisted funds are re-scored every quarter.

The hard gates

Some checks are pass-or-fail conditions rather than part of the score. Each check uses a publicly available source.

CheckRuleSourceIf it fails
Track recordAt least 3 years of NAV historyFund NAV dataNot ranked at all
Fund sizeLatest month-end AUM of ₹500 crore or moreAMC monthly AUMNot ranked at all
ConcentrationTop 10 stocks above 55% of the portfolioMonthly portfolioRanked, with a risk flag
Manager tenureCurrent manager on the scheme for 3 yearsAMC factsheetKept off the shortlist
AMC governanceNo SEBI enforcement action in the last 3 yearsSEBI ordersKept off the shortlist

If a fund fails a quality gate, it is left off the shortlist and reviewed manually, instead of simply receiving a lower score. This makes it easy to see why a fund was or was not shortlisted.

The score: 14 factors, one number

Funds that pass the gates are ranked on 14 factors, grouped into three buckets. For each factor, a fund receives a percentile rank from 0 to 100 within its category. These ranks are then weighted and combined into a single score out of 100.

Returns (30%) 1-year and 3-year point-to-point returns, plus 1-year and 3-year rolling returns over 10 years. Rolling returns measure performance from every possible start date, so a single good or bad period does not distort the result.

Consistency (25%) How often the fund sat in the top quartile of its category, and how often it beat its benchmark, over 10 years.

Risk-adjusted (45%) Alpha (the return earned above the benchmark), upside and downside capture, maximum drawdown (the deepest fall from a peak), beta (sensitivity to market swings), and the Sharpe, Sortino and information ratios (return per unit of risk, and how steadily the fund outperforms).

The market lens

The weights of the three buckets change with overall market valuations. When markets are expensive, more weight is given to risk-adjusted measures and less to returns, to place more emphasis on downside protection.

Market valuationReturnsConsistencyRisk-adjusted
Fair value or cheaper30%25%45%
Overvalued25%25%50%
Deeply overvalued20%25%55%

Debt, hybrid and gold funds are assessed differently

Debt funds use a separate 9-factor model that includes credit quality, the share of the portfolio in the highest-rated and government securities.

Hybrid funds give extra weight to downside protection.

Gold funds all track the same price, so the fund with the lowest expense ratio is selected.

Beyond the numbers: the qualitative overlay

The quantitative score is based on past performance. To add a forward-looking view, the research team meets fund managers and AMC product teams. These meetings cover six areas:

  • Fund manager meetings: Their process, conviction and how decisions actually get made.
  • Portfolio construction: Concentration, position sizing, turnover and cash calls.
  • Views ahead: Where the manager sees opportunity and risk.
  • Allocation breakup: Market-cap and sector mix against the mandate and peers.
  • Macro views: Rates, the earnings cycle, valuations and flows.
  • Product team: Mandate changes, risk controls and succession planning.

Step 4: Reviewing on a schedule

Every shortlisted fund is re-scored each quarter. A fund is flagged for review if its score declines or a significant event occurs. The research framework itself is also reviewed on a fixed schedule.

Disclaimer: Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks; read all scheme-related documents carefully. Past performance may or may not be sustained in future. This article is for information only and is not investment advice. The framework is reviewed periodically and may be updated.